Five Thoughts on the Popularity of Steampunk

Weird Tales editorial director Stephen H. Segal was recently privileged to be a guest at Dragon*Con, the nation’s largest fan-run fantasy/science-fiction/gaming/comics/etc convention. The entire event was spectacular, but Stephen particularly enjoyed taking part in a panel discussing how steampunk — science-fictiony stuff built on Victorian-era technology and aesthetics — has suddenly leapt from being a simple literary subgenre to an all-out alternative-style trend. Sure, there are great steampunk books (including a definitive new anthology coedited by WT’s own Ann VanderMeer), but now there are also steampunk fashion & jewelry designers, radio shows, and rock bands. Here, crossposted from Fantasy-Magazine.com, is Stephen’s take on what might be fueling the excitement:

1. IT’S GEEKERY THE GENDERS CAN SHARE.

On the most basic, most appealing social level, steampunk is a way to masculinize romance. That is to say: Steampunk takes something stereotypically feminine that most boys hate — Victorian lace and frills and tea and crumpets — and says, “Hey, how about some robots with that?” It’s like the Dance Dance Revolution of nerd culture: now we all have something we can play together!

2. AN AESTHETIC RESPONSE TO THE SCIENCE FICTION IN THE CULTURE.

The ’80s and ’90s gave us totally ergonomic sci-fi, as seen in Star Trek: The Next Generation — smooth, glossy black touch panels that call up whatever display you want, then you wave your hand goodbye and there’s no mess. Picard’s Enterprise led straight to the iMac: clean, happy technology with rounded edges. Which is great in that it’s completely user-friendly — but terrible in that “user-friendly” means “predictable” means “totally not exciting at all.” Having 120 gigabytes of information storage in solid-state flash memory is like having the entire knowledge of a hundred ancient libraries of Alexandria in your pocket. But who the hell wants to explore your pocket?

Steampunk says: Let’s store that knowledge in a colossal mechanical brain the size of a skyscraper that runs on punch cards, and whenever we want to know something, we’ll get to feed in our punch card and watch it go zipping and flipping through a behemoth full of gears, all the way summoning little clockwork librarians to spring up from behind panels and inscribe notes on it with miniature styluses, and they will all be well-oiled except that one that’s just screech-screech-screeching up a storm all along its track, and the spectacle will be frakking awesome.

3. LIKE BEING GOTH WITHOUT SCARING YOUR PARENTS.

A lot of kids in today’s steampunk music & style scene used to identify with the goth aesthetic — and are pleasantly surprised to discover that normal adults seem intrigued by this new thing rather than alarmed. Well, yeah. People think of goths as weirdoes who take vampires too seriously, and therefore they can’t help being worried on some level that a crazy goth might, you know, want to make them bleed. Whereas steampunks are — what? Weirdoes who take pocket-watches too seriously? What are they gonna do, vehemently tell you what time it is?

4. BRIDGING THE SUBGENRE GAP.

Sure, steampunk “proper” may simply be retro-alternate-19th-century science fiction — but in practice, writers and artists and filmmakers and musicians are all starting with this basic aesthetic and then mixing in some fantasy, some horror, some superheroics. We’re seeing steampunk pirates, steampunk faeries, steampunk Wonder Woman, steampunk Cthulhu cultists! Steampunk is helping to bring us back to the days when the subgenre categories didn’t matter so much and it was all just a big lurching conceptual mass of “weird fiction” — and we’re realizing that it’s really rather a lot of fun that way.

5. THE FUTURE: UR DOIN IT WRONG.

The heyday of science fiction — the mid-20th century — was fueled by near-universal excitement about the promise of science. We had a definite vision of “The Future,” in which the details might be variable but the overall picture was clear: new discoveries and technologies would lead us to a glorious golden age, in which robots would free us from drudgery and we’d use rocket ships to colonize the galaxy, redeeming manifest destiny in the name of all humanity together. That future — that was IT. We were going there. Our parents knew their grandkids would have jetpacks.

…except not. Today, that classic vision of the future — not only hasn’t it happened, but right at this moment, as we stare down the barrel of resource shortages and rising global temperatures, the people of Earth don’t really believe it’s going to. We know now that 20th-century technology helped us solve lots of problems while creating entirely new ones that might be even scarier. In effect, we were expecting Star Trek and we got Blade Runner; all the quirky little bits of science fiction have come true, but we lost the big dream.

Steampunk basically lets us go back, at least in our imagination, and try again — lets us tap into that sense of wonder at the unfolding universe that our grandparents might have felt when modern science was just beginning to open up all its incredible new pictures of the world. And you might just call that escapism into nostalgia — but I actually think it’s more than that.

Whether you’re reading and identifying with Girl Genius or making yourself a pair of functioning telescopic brass goggles, the fact is that when you have to get your hands or brain dirty puzzling out how stuff works, you can’t be blasé about technological miracles — you’re forced to realize what miracles we’ve actually wrought. And once you’ve got that sense of appreciation, once you’re not taking all our modern-day scientific accomplishments for granted because you finally understand deep down that people had to sweat them out, experiment by experiment — it seems to me you can’t help but approach the world around us, here, today, with fresher eyes and a more adventuresome spirit.

I think that’s where a lot of the young people jumping on the steampunk bandwagon right now are coming from. It’s not just cool because it’s trendy — it’s cool because it’s inspirational. You know… like science fiction at its best always has been.

Related Steampunkery:


Stephen H. Segal is the editorial & creative director of WEIRD TALES. He was first introduced to the concept of Victorian-looking science fiction in the early 1980s, while peeking around the back of the couch to sneak surreptitious glimpses of Tom Baker-era Doctor Who.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

27 Responses to “Five Thoughts on the Popularity of Steampunk”

  1. Suzanne Forbes Says:

    “What are they gonna do, vehemently tell you what time it is?”
    OMG awesome!

  2. Tkar Says:

    =O best discription of the best Genre ever!!!!

    Future, ur doin it wrong… love it!!!

  3. Skittle Says:

    Very well written. :-)

  4. Mary Says:

    Very good article, and I would also like to throw out there that I loved the “Weird Tales Then and Now” panel at Dragon*Con.
    H.P. Lovecraft = Original Emo Boy….. absolutely brilliant!! *big grin*

  5. Lucas Says:

    Stephen, you were definately a hilight of that panel. The comparison of Steampunk to Dance Dance Revolution was inspired.

    I particularly enjoy the idea of people wanting to go back and try again, getting the joy and thrill of invention by reinventing things from a different perspective. Tapping into problem solving and inspiration, and celebrating people who find interesting, personality-filled ways to do things that we could already do more effectively, if less interestingly.

  6. Katja Says:

    I die of funny! And also really insightful and delightfully well written. …which isn’t a sentence that really worked out all that well, but I’m glad someone who’s better with words than I am came along and wrote all that down, particularly the bits about how it’s SUPPOSED to be about being *inspired* and about getting your hands and brain dirty. Good on ya! Truly, nail’s been nailed.

  7. Joseph Says:

    Oh dear. Just when I finally got over my decades-long withdrawal from “Space: 1889″, along comes Girl Genius and steampunk. Good thing I’m retired - I spent an entire day reading GG from start to present. Siiigh. A perfectly good intervention gone down in flames like the Hindenburg.

    Now where did I put my grandad’s pocket watch…?

  8. Divatology » Blog Archive » Five Thoughts on the Popularity of Steampunk. Says:

    [...] is the title of this piece by Stephen H. Segal, who is editorial director of Weird [...]

  9. Del.icio.us op 20 september 2008 | Michel Vuijlsteke's weblog Says:

    [...] - WEIRD TALES: magazine of the gothic, fantastic & bizarre » Blog Archive » Five Thoughts on the… (tags: writing [...]

  10. scott2218 Says:

    Hey, Abney Park is Grreat!

  11. Tobu Says:

    IT’S ONE O’CLOCK–!! D:< (Take that.)

    Excellent article, with interesting insights and a few nifty new ideas that hadn’t occurred to me. A good read. Thanks!

  12. Serge Says:

    Speaking of time, when, oh when, will someone release Master of the World on DVD? It’s got Vincent Price, Charles Bronson, and the coolest airship ever, the Albatross!

  13. Jake von Slatt Says:

    Nicely done!

  14. Anino Says:

    Nicely :) Thanks for the article.

  15. Emmett Davenport Says:

    Brilliant!

  16. Michael Farren Says:

    Here’s the thing that appeals to me: I’m 58 years old, mostly considered way too old in most of the sub-culturally things going ’round these days. A 58-year-old goth would be just silly. Not so with steampunk. For the first time (probably ever), I find myself getting involved in a cultural movement before it has become the Next Big Thing, and one in which being almost 60 is not a problem, not at all.
    Gives me a kind of “elder statesman” sort of feeling, if anything. This has been revelatory to me, and one hell of a lot of fun, to boot. More steam power to us all, I say.

  17. nerium Says:

    This really is a spot on example of how I regard the genre, though sometimes it’s sometimes a little too optimistic for me.

  18. Rox of Spazhouse Says:

    Stephen, I would like to add an item to why Steampunk is popular. I was at that panel dressed at an airship captain with the folding steampunk bike. When a member of the audience wanted to know about the sub-genres of Steampunk, Robert from Abney Park told the guy, in a nice way, that the movement was not going to go that way and create little cliques and groups that austrasize others because certain items were not authentic.

    The aspect of Steampunk I like the most is that it seems so easy to approach people to ask them about something cool that they have made for their outfit.

    Also it was nice to chat with you about the Weird Tales. I bought a subscription and from you at Dragon Con and have enjoyed I what received so far.

  19. Otookee Says:

    Rox, I think you mean “ostracise”, from the Greek “ostrakon”, the little potshards the Greeks used to literally vote someone off the island. “Austrasize” sounds like fun, though - when you “austrasize” someone, do they become the size of Australia? Fools! Fear the grasp of my Awesome Austrasizing Apparatus!

    I think that’s another attraction of steampunk, by the way - in the sillier versions, at least, you get to say things like the previous sentence…

  20. OrganiClockwork Says:

    Great article. Very well put, and precisely what I’ve been preaching since I got into steampunk a couple of years back.

    Oh, and in case you didn’t notice, you definitely have a comment (supposedly) from Mister Jake Von Slatt himself here. That’s a sure sign you’ve done something well.

  21. Skadi meic Beorh Says:

    The Willows Magazine regularly prints steampunk tales along with classically written ‘weird tales’– and word has it that the magazine may indeed be planning a classic reprint per issue!

  22. Steampunk music Says:

    Interesting take on the subject. Enjoyed the read :)

  23. Great insights into why Steampunk is so popular « Prof. Uncle Festa Steampunk Inventions Says:

    [...] the full article at: http://weirdtales.net/wordpress/2008/09/17/five-thoughts-on-the-popularity-of-steampunk/ by Weird Tales editorial director Stephen H. [...]

  24. Like being a Goth without scaring your parents « Prof. Uncle Festa Steampunk Inventions Says:

    [...] being a Goth without scaring your parents Posted on June 13, 2009 by jdalton3au Why is Steampunk so popular? I love this article. I think it highlights some really significant cultural trends and how people are responding [...]

  25. Goth Girl Says:

    Probably one of, if not best, examinations on steampunk.

  26. steampunk Says:

    Great article. love the steampunk aesthetic…..

  27. Erebus Says:

    I never ceases to amaze me the power of the gothic genre, I keep expecting it to drop off but it seems to keep reinventing itself.

Leave a Reply